AT LONG EFFING LAST, I can sit down and discuss Marvel's "The Avengers" upon finally SEEING the film. No more grab-assing with set rumors and TV spot footage. And I'm terribly pleased to report that I very much enjoyed this film, and can now relax with higher confidence in Marvel's inevitable sequels (highest grossing opening ever speaks for itself). That being said, I'd like to assemble the aspects of this film that really worked, and the roll each character played in creating one of comic book film's greatest achievements.
Now, I've withheld my reviews of all the previous Marvel hero films, until this new "Avengers" film was released, for a few reasons. My number one reason, was to see where Marvel was going with this. With the exception of the first Iron Man film in 2008, the other movies have been somewhat forced out, as necessary backstory to get the inevitable group feature told. I have mixed feelings regarding this method, as I feel film is first and foremost an art form. This idea of making a satisfactory film in order to make a better film later, is a little slippery. Nonetheless, "The Incredible Hulk", "Iron Man 2", "Captain America: The First Avenger" and "Thor" DID give audiences a good introduction into the characters' origin, motivation, and outlook. Personally, "Iron Man" did this the most successfully and naturally. The other films were entertaining on a basic level, and managed to do their jobs as introductory links to a bigger picture. Joss Whedon (Director of "The Avengers") had the seemingly impossible task of taking four different films with four different tones about four VERY different people, and not make it a disjointed mess. Lucky for us all, Whedon succeeded. I suppose the simplest way to organize points regarding a film about characters, would be by character- fancy that. Without further ado, here are your Avengers!
Captain America
Iron Man
Tony Stark is sort of an asshole. Sorry, but he is. But hey, I would be too! No one likes a handsome know-it-all. The audience does, because we want to BE him- but if you were on that Helicarrier, trying to get a sense of what's going on, and some guy just kept blurting out pithy remarks to EVERYTHING anyone says, you'd eventually want to punch him in the throat. However, it's because of this, that Stark manages to have the largest character arc of anyone. His self-involved ego-centric attitude is put to the test when he's forced to rely on people he'd normally never deal with. He discovers that he needs to work with people to save himself, rather than save people to help himself (that made sense in my head). He'd be Judd Nelson (The Rebel)
Thor
This character is a tougher one to squeeze into an archetype, as he's mostly just along for the ride. I suppose his roll would be to inform the others what they're up against, having dealt with Loki in the past. But other than that, his character pretty much remains the same throughout the film. In The Breakfast Club, he'd be the library itself.
Hulk
Most astonishingly, the Hulk is the most entertaining and valuable member of the team. The excuse for his inclusion, is his genius IQ and past involvement with Gamma research, but his story becomes more than that when we see him as the Hulk. In previous films, they've attempted to make him a tortured soul that turns into a monster when bad guys try to kill him, making him the hero. This angle never felt right for the Hulk, as he isn't really a hero. The Hulk creature is a monster, and the drama resulting from that, should be out of his control. Before, we'd only ever seen him fight people that were attacking him/trying to kill him (eg, the military, brazilian gangsters, Abomination, and Nick Nolte), but when we see Hulk in this, it's more of a mental battle with himself to not hurt his friends. Eventually he is let off his chain to fight evil aliens, but when his first transformation into the Hulk comes (earlier on the Helicarrier with Black Widow), it's not a matter of simply killing bad guys. Banner transforms in a moment of frustration, and blindly attacks a helpless Scarlett Johansson, destroying his team's own ship in the process. This scene is important in establishing the problem facing Banner, and subsequently, the team. The Hulk is unstable and unsafe to have around. Banner is kind and good-hearted, but as the Hulk, knows not friend from enemy. His character arc comes when he (as the Hulk) catches an injured Iron Man, and surprises his team and himself with a moment of humanity. From a visaul aspect, I'd also like to add that this is definitely the most successful envisioning of the Hulk, and stays very true to Jack Kirby's original design. He's Anthony Michael Hall (The Brains)
S.H.I.E.L.D.
These guys/gals are secondary, and work to center the film in reality. When you've got people and aliens flying around shooting lasers, it's important to have mortal humans run out of breath and bleed here and there. Black Widow and Hawkeye are given tasks in the film that serve as menial, yet important to the plot. Hawkeye is utilized in betraying S.H.I.E.L.D. early on, and getting Loki access to their secure location. He would be Ally Sheedy (The Recluse). Black Widow is used in collecting the members of the team and making sure it's not a total sausage party. She would be Molly Ringwald (The Beauty). Agent Coulson is so wonderfully played by Clark Gregg, and is used in motivating the team, and ultimately giving them the final push they need to come together- Carl (The cooler teacher). And Nick Fury is the all important Boss. He delegates the orders and keeps his collar stiff. Mr.Vernon (The Hard Ass)
I can sit here and list every little thing about this film that worked, or maybe the little things that could have been tweaked, but I'm not going to. In all honesty, this film is a popcorn movie. It's colorful, action-packed, stars gorgeous people, and tells a story. Joss Whedon did a terrific job considering all of material he had to include, and made a great comic book film. I can't say I'm particularly looking forward to going back to a "Thor 2" or "Captain America 2", as I feel their individual tales have already been told. But I wouldn't hate a third Iron Man or fourth (but realistically all new) Hulk feature. I'm sure we'll see them all together again in more Avengers sequels, but who knows if the actors will even be reprising their rolls by then, or Whedon willing to come back. Only time will tell. As for now, we must temporarily disassemble. --Slater
Now, I've withheld my reviews of all the previous Marvel hero films, until this new "Avengers" film was released, for a few reasons. My number one reason, was to see where Marvel was going with this. With the exception of the first Iron Man film in 2008, the other movies have been somewhat forced out, as necessary backstory to get the inevitable group feature told. I have mixed feelings regarding this method, as I feel film is first and foremost an art form. This idea of making a satisfactory film in order to make a better film later, is a little slippery. Nonetheless, "The Incredible Hulk", "Iron Man 2", "Captain America: The First Avenger" and "Thor" DID give audiences a good introduction into the characters' origin, motivation, and outlook. Personally, "Iron Man" did this the most successfully and naturally. The other films were entertaining on a basic level, and managed to do their jobs as introductory links to a bigger picture. Joss Whedon (Director of "The Avengers") had the seemingly impossible task of taking four different films with four different tones about four VERY different people, and not make it a disjointed mess. Lucky for us all, Whedon succeeded. I suppose the simplest way to organize points regarding a film about characters, would be by character- fancy that. Without further ado, here are your Avengers!
For this film to work, it needed someone to relate to right away, and the Cap was that. He isn't a rich genius, he isn't a demi god, and he isn't a giant monster. He has enhanced abilities, but that only aids him in battle- and makes his jumping from explosion to explosion more explicable. So he's pretty much just a regular guy, placed on a ship with a bunch of wacky characters, with no real plan other than to hear out what Nick Fury has to say. He's not a genius, but he's not dumb either. He's inherently good, but also not afraid to call out Tony Stark for being a C-word. There are a lot of subtle moments in this film where you're not really sure what everyone's deal is, or if Banner and Stark are dedicated to S.H.I.E.LD, whether Nick Fury is being honest about his plans, or if Loki is actually smart or just insane. In these moments, it's the Cap's roll to keep an open mind, and see where the story takes us. As far as his character traits are concerned, The captain is... well, a CAPTAIN. In a situation when you have a pack of strays with different abilities coming together, his character is needed to be the assertive one and take charge. This film managed that with Cap calling the shots in the climactic battle. He uses his military tactical skill to put characters where their abilities are most needed, whether it be scrambling the outer perimeter, bottle-necking ranks, or just "Smash". If this were The Breakfast Club, Captain
America would be Emilio Estevez (The Jock).
Iron Man
Tony Stark is sort of an asshole. Sorry, but he is. But hey, I would be too! No one likes a handsome know-it-all. The audience does, because we want to BE him- but if you were on that Helicarrier, trying to get a sense of what's going on, and some guy just kept blurting out pithy remarks to EVERYTHING anyone says, you'd eventually want to punch him in the throat. However, it's because of this, that Stark manages to have the largest character arc of anyone. His self-involved ego-centric attitude is put to the test when he's forced to rely on people he'd normally never deal with. He discovers that he needs to work with people to save himself, rather than save people to help himself (that made sense in my head). He'd be Judd Nelson (The Rebel)
Thor
This character is a tougher one to squeeze into an archetype, as he's mostly just along for the ride. I suppose his roll would be to inform the others what they're up against, having dealt with Loki in the past. But other than that, his character pretty much remains the same throughout the film. In The Breakfast Club, he'd be the library itself.
Hulk
Most astonishingly, the Hulk is the most entertaining and valuable member of the team. The excuse for his inclusion, is his genius IQ and past involvement with Gamma research, but his story becomes more than that when we see him as the Hulk. In previous films, they've attempted to make him a tortured soul that turns into a monster when bad guys try to kill him, making him the hero. This angle never felt right for the Hulk, as he isn't really a hero. The Hulk creature is a monster, and the drama resulting from that, should be out of his control. Before, we'd only ever seen him fight people that were attacking him/trying to kill him (eg, the military, brazilian gangsters, Abomination, and Nick Nolte), but when we see Hulk in this, it's more of a mental battle with himself to not hurt his friends. Eventually he is let off his chain to fight evil aliens, but when his first transformation into the Hulk comes (earlier on the Helicarrier with Black Widow), it's not a matter of simply killing bad guys. Banner transforms in a moment of frustration, and blindly attacks a helpless Scarlett Johansson, destroying his team's own ship in the process. This scene is important in establishing the problem facing Banner, and subsequently, the team. The Hulk is unstable and unsafe to have around. Banner is kind and good-hearted, but as the Hulk, knows not friend from enemy. His character arc comes when he (as the Hulk) catches an injured Iron Man, and surprises his team and himself with a moment of humanity. From a visaul aspect, I'd also like to add that this is definitely the most successful envisioning of the Hulk, and stays very true to Jack Kirby's original design. He's Anthony Michael Hall (The Brains)
![]() |
| (Left: Jack Kirby's 1960's Hulk / Right: 2012's "The Avengers" Hulk) |
S.H.I.E.L.D.
These guys/gals are secondary, and work to center the film in reality. When you've got people and aliens flying around shooting lasers, it's important to have mortal humans run out of breath and bleed here and there. Black Widow and Hawkeye are given tasks in the film that serve as menial, yet important to the plot. Hawkeye is utilized in betraying S.H.I.E.L.D. early on, and getting Loki access to their secure location. He would be Ally Sheedy (The Recluse). Black Widow is used in collecting the members of the team and making sure it's not a total sausage party. She would be Molly Ringwald (The Beauty). Agent Coulson is so wonderfully played by Clark Gregg, and is used in motivating the team, and ultimately giving them the final push they need to come together- Carl (The cooler teacher). And Nick Fury is the all important Boss. He delegates the orders and keeps his collar stiff. Mr.Vernon (The Hard Ass)
I can sit here and list every little thing about this film that worked, or maybe the little things that could have been tweaked, but I'm not going to. In all honesty, this film is a popcorn movie. It's colorful, action-packed, stars gorgeous people, and tells a story. Joss Whedon did a terrific job considering all of material he had to include, and made a great comic book film. I can't say I'm particularly looking forward to going back to a "Thor 2" or "Captain America 2", as I feel their individual tales have already been told. But I wouldn't hate a third Iron Man or fourth (but realistically all new) Hulk feature. I'm sure we'll see them all together again in more Avengers sequels, but who knows if the actors will even be reprising their rolls by then, or Whedon willing to come back. Only time will tell. As for now, we must temporarily disassemble. --Slater


















